Division of Historic Services
Vox Populi….Seeing a lot of comments asked for a voice over, we decided to add VO in our latest video, covering the roman republican legion – https://youtu.be/Wn7ZrPjcW6Y
yup, good strategy….
Perché il titolo è in italiano ma il video in inglese?Coglione, mi hai rubato una visualizzazione, se scopro chi sei ti prendo a schiaffi
Without reading the comments, i predict a epic battle between wannabe historians 😂😂
Duck of rome
Macedonian phalanx 💪
Amazing YT Chanel. Very good animation.
Visit Rome before Rome visit you
Next: Legion vs Mark 15 Phalanx CIWS
No cavalry in the right Greek flank, legions reaching the phalanx while the other division isn’t in battle formation and way behind the front line. Philipp V trying to play Alexander but fails miserably
Uhhh being outnumbered by 10000 people might have something to do with it .
Modern army vs old army. Modern army has numbers advantage. If commander of modern army are at least not fool, this is clear win, even before battle started.
' The battle is considered one of the best examples of manipular roman legion superiority over the macedonian phalanx'
Well actually, this battle showed the complete opposite.There were actually 2 parts to the battle where greeks fought Romans on roughly equal terms – firstly when both sets of scouts got reinforced and fought, secondly when the greek right flank of heavy infantry fought the Roman left flank of heavy infantry.
Both these times, greeks were winning the fight and pushing the Romans back.
They only won because of a tactical move by the Roman right flank of heavy infantry, which cleaned the greek left off the battlefield while they were still setting up, and cleaned the greek right off the field by hitting them up the arse – both maneuvers which often throughout history have been used to defeat forces much superior anyway.
This, with all due respect, sucked.
12 min vid would have been summarized in 1 min reading of perhaps 3-4 pages. Alternately use the graphic as a very small help to the wiki: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Cynoscephalae
Holds high ground with a solid line. Half of his army not on the field. And he charges down. Zzzzz
I was more interested in the actual tactics of a Phalanx vs a Legion
When both sides know what they are doing the sword loses to the spear.
It's 6 year* old son, not 6 years old son
Interesting. Excellent job, and the analysis is left to us really. Interesting how weak the phalanx is to the rear, I never thought about that.
Una centuria de legionarios VS 100 vikingos quien gana?
Skip to 9:45 to begin to see fucking blocks moving towards each other
How do we know this is what happened? What is the source?
Legion > phalanx
its not exactly which was better the phalanx or the legions, it's more how effective the commanders are at deploying and utilising their formations along with many other factors
more like high ground vs war elephants
The Roman Tribune of the right flank that turned his unit to attack the Macedonian Phalanx in the rear decided the battle for the Romans. 😘Excellent work – I for one am looking forward to many more videos of the same quality with narrative ! 😍
greeks finaly contained the persian advance greeks: who could stop us now?Rome: nice to meet you
Wow the new Infinity war movie looks great
it's nonsense, how the macedonians cant form up a battle line on the right? lol. so the macedonians let the romans close beacuse the macedonians have no brain to form a battleline…ok bro ok…
Jehovah God needed the roman empire to build a communication system, roads, so that the Gospel of his Son would spread through out the empire and world. but still, very cool battle field tactics and maneuvering: high level of discipline is a perquisite.
Good presentation, very informative. Plenty of misspellings and bad grammar as well.
"Our men are fleeing the field of battle, this is a shameful display"
Imagine the discipline you would need as a soldier. The Romans basically sacrificed a third of their army for the chance to surround the Phalanx. Why did they not smash the Phalanx with their elephants from the side though to break their battle formation?
The battle starts around 5:50
First video I watched and it was amazing! Nicely done, maybe a good narrator would enchant this even more 😀
he should have brought all of his army with him when he march to the battle and he would win the battle.
The music is just epic.
Can't read the comments, don't know what is going on.
Los macedonios perdieron por falta de tropas y de coordinación, se podía dar vuelta la historia
Ich kann nicht nachvollziehen, warum im Titel mit Deutsch geworben wird, wenn die Texte nur in Englisch hinterlegt sind 🤨 ich würde sagen: Zielgruppe verfehlt!
They should have organised the phalanx in such a way that the back rows could be commanded to turn around to protect the rear.
What is the music used in the battle portion of the video?
And then Bunch of Hunnic bandits destroyed And slaughtered Romans
All I have to say is, What a violent world we live in!!!!
Repubblica contro Re legione
hold the high ground … unite and keep holding it … if you can … imagine if the war elephants had the high ground …. ouch
Lazy. Cut the music and make the letters bigger at the very least. Commintary would have been the best way to go. But content is good.
The English is very poorly written. Grammar lessons may be in order.
This video is excellent. Excellent as is. I'll check the audio version which may be better but music which I think is a good addition probably be in the audio version. Whatever the case the video is a treat.
If only the tribune on the west flank of the assaulting 'reserve right flank' had communicated his intentions and maintained contact with Flaminus, then the reserve forces of the 'reserve right flank' left behind atop the eastern ridge could have moved west along the ridge to intercept the retreating Macedonians, and then trap the Macedonians during the route between two Roman armies.
Not bad, but the text in English is not very good and requires improvement.
So sad for Greece (
hard to watch Video while reading a Book… Im gone
No voice. I'll go read a book.
i love it when colored boxes attack the other colored boxes!
In the immortal words of Flaminus, "Runaway!"
HOLY F*****G S**T ITS THE WROMANSRUN AWAY
I thought that was simple and well done
Wow! What is that music?
It's more like the maginot line vs the German blitzkreig.
No army "routs" from the field, as is the characterization of the losing Macedonians in this otherwise educational animation.
The term is: they are "routed" from the field. The Romans are the force who "routed" them. No army "routs" itself. Sheesh.
Was this a test proving Phalanx was inferior to Legion? Don't think so.
One independent-thinking Roman officer made the difference.
Otherwise, it was one surprised general beating the other by a whisker, after both armies had been split into two groups.
Seems like the Phalanx lost due to a fluke error of not having the battle line ready prior to the Romans attacking.. The phalanx is a stronger fighting force.
η φαλαγγα των μακεδονων οπως κ η λεγεωνα των ρωμαιων δεν ηταν κατι σταθεροοποτε πριν μιλησουμε για ανωτεροτητα της μιας η της αλλης στο τακτικο κ στον τομεα της ευκινησιας η της ευκολης διαχειρισης στην μαχη πρεπει να δουμε για ποια εποχη μιλαμεη ποιοτητα της εκπαιδευσης της φαλαγγας,αν δεν κανω λαθος κρατω κ μια πισινη,ειχε πεσει τοσο πολυ που απο τις χιλιαρχιες κ κατι απο την διαιρεση δηλ σε πολες ταξεις που αυξαναν την ευκινησια την ευκολια διοικησης κ προστεθαν επιλογες στον διοικητη εφτασαν να αποτελουνται απο δυο τμηματα το δεξι κ το αριστερο με αποτελεσμα καθε φορα που θελεις πχ να αλλαξεις μετωπο να αναγκαζεσαι να μετακινεις 8000 φαλαγγιτες κ οχι 1000+ η πολλαπλασιο αυτου
Haven't watched this yet but come on, outnumbered and even with a large slice of mercenaries sill outnumbered. The Romans wouldn't have fought if it wasn't so.
Too much overly loud Thump thump thump music! Very bad production, no narration!
PRETTY MUCH USELESS VID – NO NARRATOR do you nerds actually think anybody sits infront of the screen with their nose glued to it to read every word ? I pay more attention to Sanford and Son than these type vids
What a fucking bad-ass name is "Titus Flaminius" ? XD
Titus father : what you want to be when you are an adult ?Titus Flaminius : BARRITUS !!!
That tribune that flanked became instantly rich after the battle
It was really the elephants that carried the day.
Why do people insist on stuffing their videos with dumb music?
I haven't watched the video yet, but I subscribed because this looks awesome.
No triangles or rectangles were harmed in the making of this video
so they did not expect to run into eachother the high ground always wins
Read a really great 'faction' book about this, sadly I can't remember the authors name.Great video.
Phalanx [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phalanx_(comics) ] vs Legion [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legion_(Marvel_Comics) ] [?!] wow! awesome! ;P
ROME TOTAL WAR 2019 BIATCH YOYO 😉
Phillip was an idiot to divide his forces.
In the Second Punic War , demostrated…Víctory for the Legion
An interesting and well presented account of the battle. But based on the title, I was expecting to learn about the differences between phalanxes and legions.
One thing not mentioned in this was that the Roman Legions had a flexibilty to them that was not found in the phalanx
Good to learn history this way
Typo, it's "renounce".
Tactics seem to be what defeated the phalanxes, not the legions.
video straordinario non avete nulla di simile relativo alleimprese di giulio cesare?
Bad ass Romans for the win.
WHY HAVE YOU STOPPED MAKING VIDEOS?????????????????????????????????
The fact that phillip took so long for the rest of the phalanx to go in position is painful to watch. Extremely annoying
How many did the Romans loose? Did they loose more but win because of numbers?
⚠️ Reproduction, reupload, rebroadcast, and distribution of my copyrighted videos are prohibited.
A falanx must be protected by all support troops. Nothing of that was then. And even terein. The Greeks loved Rome. And Rome loved Greece 👏
I thought I was watching a video not reading a video…? I guess it's just way too hard to narrate it… You lazy bastard!!!
Go ahead and fuck around and throw some Romans at a 400 BC Spartan Phalanx and see how many Spartans die compared to Romans ( don't bring up anything about Spartans around 200 BC because during that times a bunch of randoms from the Greek world were running Sparta and new nothing about the Spartan culture, therefore they ended up losing for the first time EVER using a phalanx but it wasn't against any Romans.) in other words Sparta all the way up to like 350 BC were run by real Spartans until the collapse of there military power, and no people there military strength was not over exaggerated, take a navy seal or a DELTA Force member who has been training for 5-10 years maybe a little bit more knowing that they are already bad ass, and combine them with the natural human strength of way back in ancient times and add about 20-30 more years of training and see what you get. Thats how Spartans were made.
Μαπα το καρπουζι
Where did Rome get the War Elephants from? I thought they didn’t get any until they fully conquered Greece and the Carthaginians.
В России сравнили фалангу и легионIn Russia compared phalanx and Legionhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oz2D25wiDZk
Interesting but it doesn't explain the superiority of legion over phalanx; and why was the commentary done by Google Translate?
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.